Unfair Dismissal Claims for Employees

Where an employee has two years, or more, continuous service, an employer must have (1) a fair reason to dismiss them and (2) follow a fair procedure to dismiss them.

The potentially fair reasons to dismiss are:

  • Misconduct at work;
  • Lack of capacity (or qualifications) to do the job;
  • Redundancy;
  • A statutory requirement;
  • Some other substantial reason.

A fair procedure should be a procedure that is in accordance with the ACAS Code of Conduct.

In certain circumstances, the employer must also show that the decision to dismiss is within the range of reasonable responses (to a particular situation) available to an employer.

There are certain limited cases where a dismissal will be automatically unfair and in those situations the employee will not need to have been employed for two years. If that is the case, the employee only has to be able to demonstrate to a Tribunal that the dismissal was for one of the automatically unfair reasons to succeed in their claim. These include, for example, being dismissed for:

  • Membership (or non-membership) of a Trade Union or for Trade Union activities;
  • Pregnancy or any other reason connected with the pregnancy;
  • For making a protected disclosure (whistleblowing);
  • Discriminatory reasons.

Discrimination claims are complicated and it is recommended that any employee who believes that they are being discriminated against takes legal advice. Our experienced team would be pleased to provide that advice.

Get in touch

Name(Required)

Meet the Employment team

What our customers say

AI RS22

“I cannot thank Anna and her at team enough for the exceptional support and representation she provided during my maternity redundancy case. From the start, she showed genuine empathy, deep legal expertise, and a clear commitment to protecting my rights. Navigating a redundancy situation while on maternity leave was incredibly stressful, but Anna guided me…

AI RS 13

“Anna Illingworth was helping me with an issue I have about disability discrimination in the workplace. She provided professional advice and a realistic approach together with empathy and understanding of the situation not only from my professional but also from my personal perspective.”

AI – RS5

“I used the services of Rowberry Morris to negotiate a Settlement Agreement with my employer. The work had to be done quickly due to the two-week deadline imposed by my employer. Despite the challenges imposed by the COVID crisis, the Solicitor and their assistant communicated very effectively, clearly explained my options and reached a settlement…

excellent job

“Please pass on my appreciation and thanks to Anna Illingworth.  I thought she did an excellent job, reaffirming the very wide scope of expertise offered by Rowberry Morris to its clients.

AI – RS1

“Would highly recommend. Very professional team and I am grateful for all the support I have received and the end result.”

AI – RS10

“An excellent, friendly service from start to finish. I was kept informed of progress and was told about the costs in the beginning. I have used Rowberry Morris for other matters so it was and will remain a natural first call if ever I need their services.”

AI – RS6

“Professional, effective, fast and very approachable service.”

AI RS 14

“I would highly recommend Anna because of how she helped me to navigate a long-standing situation. With her help, I was eventually able to come to a conclusion – allowing me to finally start moving on with my life.”

AI – RS7

“Rowberry Morris and Anna Illingworth were recommended to myself. Although a short employment exit review, everything was explained to me clearly with chance to query or confirm understanding. Great care was taken and required changes were raised and were all accepted by my now ex-employer. I felt that the advice was clear and that I…

AI – RS10

“An excellent, friendly service from start to finish. I was kept informed of progress and was told about the costs in the beginning. I have used Rowberry Morris for other matters so it was and will remain a natural first call if ever I need their services.”

AI RS17

“We were put in touch with Anna at Rowberry Morris by our HR advisors, who recommended engaging with her in relation to an ongoing issue we have with an ex-member of staff. Anna and the team were brilliant from start to finish, providing reassurance, great advice and dealing with a situation professionally and without the…

KB – Google 1

“I’ve dealt with Rowberry Morris twice and in both cases they were excellent and secured the desired result with great communication, advice and guidance throughout. I won’t hesitate to use them again in the future. Thank you again Peter and Katherine.”